Destructoid Checkpoint: I love the weird review discourse

I'm a glutton for punishment.

The biggest game of the decade has just dropped, and while the Destructoid team is doing an admirable job talking about it, I've decided to use it more as a jumping-off point than a target. The discourse around these huge cultural moments is always very interesting, and the review scores for GTA 6, which has done incredibly well with critics, are once again making people feel disconnected from what reviews are, or at least from what they think they should be.

I always find the conversation around the process and purpose of reviews to be incredibly interesting. The scope and scale of the debate tends to mean everyone tries to treat the “other side” as a monolith. Consumers surely want one thing from reviews, while outlets want another. Truthfully, it just isn’t that simple, because people have an overly simplistic view of what reviews are.

Win GTA VI Ultimate Edition (and get ready for Vice City)

GTA VI lands on November 19, and GTA 6 Bible is giving away 20 copies of GTA VI Ultimate Edition to celebrate. Entering takes about a minute: create a free GTA 6 Bible account with Google or Discord, then tell us your first move in Vice City with #GTA6Bible on Instagram, TikTok, X, YouTube Shorts or our Facebook post.

While you’re in, your free account unlocks everything you need for launch week:

  • An interactive Leonida map where you can pin locations and track collectibles

  • Cheats, mission guides and walkthroughs, updated as the game drops

  • Character and vehicle profiles for everything confirmed so far

  • The Vice Gazette, our free GTA 6 newsletter

  • The GTA6 Bible companion app, so the map sits on your phone while you play

Entries close December 7. Click here to enter the giveaway.

No purchase necessary. US residents 18+. Ends 12/7/26, 11:59 PM PT. Rules at gta6bible.com/giveaways. GTA6 Bible is an unofficial fan site, not affiliated with Rockstar Games or Take-Two Interactive.

Subjective vs Objective

This was one of the dumbest debates around reviews in the last decade. Why? Because it assumed that these two elements are somehow incongruous with each other. This argument—and the social media upheavals that drove it onward—is undone by the simple fact that reviews are both. And I don’t mean that some reviews are subjective and some are objective; I mean every review worth reading is both at the same time. 

The objective element is the game itself: the music, the graphics, the art direction, the design decisions, the approach to the story and narrative. All of these are what they are and can only ever be described factually. Bugs are bugs, glitches are glitches, and mechanics are mechanics. Good writers focus on trying to describe them, and while these parts of reviews run the risk of being sterile, they are completely necessary. 

The subjective element is how the reviewer reacts to these objective elements. Do they like them or dislike them? Do they spark happiness or anger in the author? Does the reviewer consider them to have been well executed? What emotions are evoked by cutscenes? Do they land well? Does the tone of the game match the theme? There are endless subjective questions that a reviewer might opt to focus on, but the ones included will always be a smattering of their overall thoughts.

My point is that both elements sit beside each other in importance. A good review will give you an understanding of whether a game is for you, even if you disagree with the reviewer on everything they have to say about it.

The element of the bargain

The real awkwardness and interest of a review is in the intangible. What is the reviewer willing to forgive, and why? Is a bug recurrent but not game-breaking, or even that annoying? Is there a tradeoff that they are happy to make? Is a poor story something to overlook if the gameplay is top-notch? 

Some people just have patience for poor performance, while others don’t mind hammy writing or voice acting. One might deduct a point where the other doesn’t. Remember, you need to be able to decide that negative elements are worth a 10% reduction in a score on most websites, because of the common 1-10 scaling that places use. That is why you will see reviewers who give a game a 10/10 score but will still mention some issues or potential flaws. A 10/10 should not be an indicator of a perfect game, but rather a title that comes pretty damn close and takes the crown in its genre, but ultimately something t the reviewer feels is an essential experience, something you should play if you are a fan of the medium.

It’s hard to tell a reviewer's taste from a single review

As a consumer, the most important thing you can do is expose yourself to a variety of websites, writers, YouTubers, and reviewers of all types. A single review can tell you about a game, but it cannot tell you about the reviewer. Do they have a preference for certain design elements that you also like? Do they have a long history with a franchise, or are they viewing it with fresh eyes? 

Only you can decide what you feel is important in a review, then find reviewers and outlets that match your freak. I always say that if you find a reviewer who expresses similar tastes and interests to you, then hold them close, but never trust them blindly. What they like might change, or you might even change yourself. Stranger things have happened.

The main mistake to avoid is thinking that a publication has some kind of consensus across its reviewers. Nope, Destructoid did not give X game Y score. Our reviewer did. We try to create a space where people can be honest about their take on a game, and that means that they will be free to express themselves however they wish. 

Some reviews are just really bad

An often-ignored part of the issue, especially from my peers in the industry, is that some reviewers are bad. I don’t mean poorly written, but rather not fit for purpose. It is my belief that a reader should possess both an understanding of what a game is offering and how a writer feels about it by the end of the review.

I have read some reviews where the reviewer seemed to forget that they were meant to be talking about a game, and instead went on a spiel about themselves. These can be interesting op-eds and features, but they are not reviews, or at the very least, they are reviews that are very much at odds with reader expectations. 

I like to approach reviews as an important element of purchasing decisions for readers. Have I helped you make an informed decision about whether you will spend your hard-earned cash? Hopefully, yes. If not, I’ve failed you and myself.

The best thing about reviews is that I could talk to ten people from around the industry, and we would all have different views on what they could, or even should, be. Ultimately, they should be a small part of your exposure to video game writing, and you should be reading or watching multiple reviews, if you value them, to help you figure out if a game might be for you or not. 

What’s happening, Destructoid?

Scott Duwe has been invoking jealousy for the last few weeks as he got to go hands-on with GTA 6 for the Destructoid review. - “Several delays, numerous leaks, an outrageous marketing push, and countless “we got X before GTA 6” memes later, the game is finally here. So, with an impossible level of hype and high expectations, has GTA 6 delivered? On just about every level imaginable…yeah.”

Tiago Manuel engaged in some video game archaeology. - “One of the most famous pieces of Final Fantasy trivia says SquareSoft picked that name because the company was in dire straits, knew it would be their last game, and wanted to go out with a bang. Cool story, bro; too bad it’s bunk.”

Andrej Barovic thinks that GTA 6 making room for pacifism might just be its bravest design choice. - “Much of GTA 6 is very clearly inspired by Red Dead Redemption 2, and integrates most of that game’s systems into its own design philosophy. The Honor system, judging your morals throughout RDR2, is also here, though it does take a somewhat different shape and is now called your “criminal profile.”

From around the GAMURS network

Cameron Palmer, GAMURS Product Marketing Manager, recently appeared on ABC (Australian Broadcast Corporation) to break down just why GTA 6 is such a big deal for folks who might know the deal. You can give it a listen at about the 1:50 mark if you wish!